I know you said you are not handy, but I bet you could handle painting and google can teach you a lot to DIY.

@Russell Alton the column headers are missing and its confusing looking at the numbers.

South Philly is also a great bet too.

Your best bet would be to review the information they should've sent you to see what they cover.

Your best bet in this case may be to do a short sale, rent for a few years, then buy another house.You may be able to borrow from your 401k for the down payment.

With about 125k$ on hand I know my best bet to stretch my money would be to BRRR method properties.

In the early days of my real estate career, I would buy nothing down properties strictly betting on appreciation.  

It was easy to see once you see the decline of the Big Three Automakers over the decades.The fact is that NYC is diverse in virtually all Verticals, making it actually a safer bet than a one trick pony town like Detroit was back then.So, as long as I am investing in a City and Neighborhood that is Diverse Economically, then I only need to worry about the the rest of the areas which could impact my portfolio.I'm an Expert in my very specific locality.

It may take some effort but it's your best bet to find someone with a track record of playing by the rules. 

A good bet for the insurance company.