The property was sitting on the market for about 30 days due to the condition, seasonality (it was December), and smaller size of the property (about 1300 sqft). 

If anyone knows of a good market without restrictive zones, please let me know.

Look at other things like their presence online and how they handle themselves online and on forums.

But currently my goal is only to continue to buy maybe 1-2 off market holding/investment properties a year, so I generally didn't use these services enough to continue the subscription for long.

Meaning that if tragedy happened and the unit was unusable, they'd cover market rent.

The last market valuation of this property was ~650k.

One thought is if what you are doing already is working why are you looking to move markets? 

I'm in the process of choosing a market to focus on and wanted input on strong BRRRR markets right now.

When you're fully ready for analysis check out the renter analysis tools and don't be afraid to post questions and ask for help, everyone is really supportive :) A good first step and great lending resource (super important in today's market) might be to check in with my lending guide and bestie of 20+ years @Joseph Chiofalo they lend nationwide and he's very patient with newbies and can help craft a workable plan towards portfolio growth.

You will learn so much from people who know the market and they will also have resources that will be useful to you.As for the properties themselves, it never hurts to start looking.