I'm in the process of trying to get this done soon to eliminate that concern.My issue with the garage is, most houses in my sub-dividson have fully functional garages, so I would like to use this property as a lesson's learned and take the projected $80k that I may make on this home if I do sell it and use that money to invest in another property that is in better condition when the market is better for buyers 1-2 years down the road.I will also potentially be moving away (over 8 hours away) from this area in about 2 years, so another reason I'm looking to maybe sell since it can be hard to find great property managers.Anyway, this is my first rental property, so I just wanted to pick the brains of others since I have a limited small view of things and maybe missing the big picture on why I should hang on to it.Note, I have been lucky enough to have 2 different tenants rent this home out since I renovated it, but after moving out, they love the house but did mention dislikes about the garage doors and basements when we asked for things they would recommend for improvement.Thanks!

We're kind of speaking in hypotheticals here and it's always hard because we don't know the property value, purchase price, condition of the shop, cost estimates, etc.Good luck!

What are the best options for fixing this section if all the other tile in the bathroom is in good condition?

)     - Deteriorated or missing shutters (Missing shutters are easiest to spot, but it seems to take a second longer to evaluate the condition of the shutters.)- Deteriorated roof (Most roofs seem easy to evaluate.

What is the condition of the property, what utilities are split, what are tenants paying for rent, etc. 

It's not just the physical condition you see that determines value.

This property is in great condition.

All my properties were off market and really distressed, but similar properties that sold for $75K (distressed/original) are selling for twice that now in the same condition. 

The sale argument tends to work for the schools, just not investors.We use comps, property photos, condition reports, purchase/rent concessions, and more to support a more accurate value.

You mentioned the FHA loan may have property condition requirements that will need to be addressed before closing.