That gave me credit history, income verification, criminal records, eviction records, etc and helped me build out a thorough lease. 

Usually, dogs are messy and the ones with not good behavior will cause some damage to the property. 

Will the inspector or the courts eventually come after me and press criminal charges?

Then I moved to a program primarily for young men with developmental disabilities but highly functional, like working at Home Depot and Fed Ex who had some criminal histories so had to be supervised, now I’m at a transitional housing facility.

If it becomes a pattern of behavior a discussion about when they receive their paychecks etc. may help if a tenant needs the rent paid at a certain date each month.

She would be all pissy about it when she would call but when you were there to address the issue she acted like she had been perfectly cordial.The name neat-freak implies an excessive behavior. 

That is one of the key behaviors that led to the housing crash ten years ago.

They can modulate their behavior when called on it.

Id suggest filing criminal reports with the appropriate authorities asap.

Watch for previous evictions, criminal background issues, length at a job and please check ALL references (landlord, employment and personal).