It doesn't care what color you are, what you cook, your tattoo's, etc.

The Fair Housing Act The Fair Housing Act (the Act) prohibits discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability, and\ familial status in most housing related transactions.

The best thing to do with things like mailboxes and paint color schemes and other "look and feel" items is to stay as neutral as possible.

Actually, the only color you should be seeing in this business is green.I would take Tenant B. 

@Robert Fountain,dated and dated, clean and new paint smell are 2 different things...i would check all competition for 0.5-1 mile radius then check all features for houses sold in the same radius.you will then know:-paint color/combination to use (neutral beige or the ever popular graige/grayish tones)-appliances common or not/expected or not (all matchy matchy)-houses features/commonalitychange counter tops and fixturesclean/rejuvenate the cabinetscheck like crazy the mechanicals: those are the #2 money eating (#1 is bad tenant or vacant property)some here on BP have removed carpet completely and refinished wood under/switched to vinyl click wood like planksgood luck

They come in a variety of colors and sizes with a nice texture. 

I used a light colored Behr exterior latex paint.

When I was doing this I was a pit-bull with underwriters who would disqualify a loan because the colors were not right.

This can be the biggest issue... even a color-change can be a no-no in some places.Good luck.

Sorta idiot proof.same way with bath and kitch floors cept use light sand color in a 12 bye 12 size.