If that is the most likely outcome given your other assumptions, no matter the return % you came up with, I suggest passing.

Of course there is future gazing involved and assumptions in all of the above but at least you have numbers that may mean something!

I have some assumptions.

Hi All,I was under the assumptions most banks allow 6 conventional loans.

You don't know if your employer will allow remote working indefinitely at this point, it is an assumption. 

Assumption is equal equity built in.

Which is way too hopeful, and shouldn't be counted on.Any ideas what is assumed, and how to make our own assumptions?

At first glance the assumptions look sound. 

(And this is with the assumption that utilities payments aren't also taxed.)If a potential tenant rented just one room upstairs and things were divided by 3, it would be $1015 without utilities and $1435 with utilities.

I assumed rents and opex don't inflate.A: profit 95k, Multiple of Capital 1.73x, IRR 13.3%, NPV @ 11% 136kB: profit 48k, Multiple of Capital 1.62x, IRR 12.1%, NPV @ 10% 84kSo, if your "goal" is for capital to maximize profit (as it "should" be) then an argument can be made for property A.That said...all these numbers are small and close enough for you to go make a decision of all the assumptions left out and what your "gut" says.