That's criminal. 

I'm thinking that's a criminal offense as well as a civil one.

Credit score of X, or no money judgements, no evictions, etc.You literally cannot predict human behavior ... a good tenant can turn into a bad tenant through no fault of the PM. 

I don't reward bad behavior with financial incentives.

I would not suggest them for complex things and they do not do criminal law which i wouldn't trust to them anyway.

You've also subconsciously trained yourself to accept bad behavior for long periods of time.Rent is due on the first day of the month.

For example, I mention that every adult must pay a $30 application fee, pass my credit/criminal background, make a combined income of 3x the rent, and whether or not the property accepts pets.

Here's the problem, I have a criminal background.

I am passionate in my disdain for him, and would love nothing more than to see him be held accountable for his intentional criminal acts against me and others I've come to learn about. 

I also politely recommended he review his statements every month to hold me accountable rather than waiting a year and forcing me to spend half a day researching historical data.If your PM makes it right and makes an effort to correct the bad behavior, they are probably worth keeping.