One house was great.

That is considered mortgage fraud and is probably one of the highest forms of mortgage fraud that happen. 

Would you be willing to share a name of the bank or how you found one?

Chances are you sent more than one letter to one person.

If you're curious, it is in one of the run-down neighborhoods of Warren, Ohio near Youngstown, Ohio.

Definitely want to consult a title attorney on that, but this is why I tell people to go with large well funded title companies rather than the cheaper local ones. 

I've been a real estate agent since 2014 working in the residential side and have one investment property (bought rented and sold) under my belt. 

Maybe a 2 bedroom split with one other person, but not this many room mates.A few things to thing about - many counties and cities limit the number of unrelated occupants to 3 or 4 people, no matter how large the house, so check to see if there is a limit in your area. 

The one that was left was in really bad shape.

In my case, I have residential rentals in one LLC, commercial properties in another, self storage in a third, and my real estate company operates in a fourth.