It was a majority decision, not unanimous though, and 4 judges dissented.

It’s not a bad decision giving everyone you have stated but it’s certainly not optimal either.

That decision paid off big time! 

I did this and that decision put me well ahead of the game.

Here are some of the major factors to take into account when making this decision.

In cheap housing, you have to make a decision to be a local, on-site landlord. 

I will look into that further before making any decisions.

I told him to borrow one of the other THREE from one of the other guys or buy one, and that they were left behind as a courtesy.Babes in the woods.But that did confirm my decision to replace the toilets when I refresh the bathroom, because his response when the toilet clogged was to flush it twice more until it "nearly overflowed" and he said that he's scared to do it again in case it does overflow. 

Are they objective in their decisions for both sides or did they seem biased in their decisions?

Congratulations on your decision to invest in teal estate!