Much of my hesitancy is buoyed by anecdotal evidence like how many people I know who have decided to leave Montgomery.

I can’t imagine doing detective work with my guys since no evidence....How would you possibly stop/reduce the chance of this happening going forward?!

If the purchase is an "Arms length transaction", the purchase contract might be enough evidence to win the appeal.

Operating Agreement CY2016 Formation- Name, LLC is registered in the state of STATE as a sole member for profit entity, effective DATE, as evident by STATE Secretary of State Certificate #999999.Overview- NAME, LLC currently operates a real estate division that is responsible for the acquisition of single and multifamily property for the purpose of rehab & resale, and buy & hold investing strategies.

I've read that I need to build a case with comps that have sold in the neighborhood, but the best comp is the actual purchase of my property as it's the best evidence of the true market value.  

I also missed a small amount of termite damage that was dormant but under Indiana law, if there is no evidence of treatment in the last five years, it must be treated if there is any damage.

I also find evidence for my stance on this subject from Dr.

However, as far as I can tell, there is no evidence that this property was ever sold (@SamKWak claims he flipped it, and that's why he was ok disclosing its address, despite the fact he posted the video within a week of purchasing the property....pretty quick flip given that the brothers are sledgehammering walls in the video)

Both physical presence (see #1 below) and evidence of intent (see #2 below) must be in place to begin the domicile year.

Basically, I am hearing conflicting reviews from two camps each with their own substantial repository of evidence.