Rather than doing a Recast, if I invest the $50K into another SFH (at a price point that’s right for me) I’ll end up with $0-100 net monthly cashflow compared to my 3 other SFHs that are producing $2200/month net monthly cash flow (cumulatively).Based on the incredible growth going on in the Boise/Meridian Treasure Valley area (with an additional 400,000 new residents expected to move into the valley in the next 30 years) is it worth it to have a rental in my portfolio that is funding its expense but not netting anything to me?  

This has been a multi-year full gut rehab and addition primarily done by myself, My fiancé is in her last year of her residency, so we will likely be moving next year.

The only immediate repairs I saw where the chimneys need retoppi g, the dtiveway needs redoing and the basement qindows need to be boarded in and insulated. the rest is cosmetics as long as the residents stay.Originally posted by @Jim Goebel:@Brian FooteHiIt's going to be hard to say precisely without knowledge of your market however those rent numbers are pretty good if I'm seeing the $1600+ for what you're getting into the property for.The 'gotchas' that I see that I'd want you to really be comfortable with would be that repair cost number - this would have to be a pretty light rehab where you're maybe doing a facelift, etc. 

I love that it has no state tax to pay-one of the reasons I make it my residence. 

The other post pretty much stated, do not get a place if it does not cash flow.Here's a hypethetical scenario..I can get a cash out refi on my primary residence for around $120k in my pocket (330 total, pay off house at 210 left on mortgage) that would change my mortgage from $1000/month to $1900/month.

Yes it is legal to rent a house you don't live in, to an extent as there is a 270 day occupancy requirement for a permanent resident; which really means that you can only rent it as a "whole house" for 95 days out of the year (I may have those days flip flopped, it may be 275 and 90).

But I don't know what would be a better option with the money.Option 1: Build a Garage with a 2BR apartment on my primary residence property.

I currently do not own a home and rent myself so I see the benefits of locally purchasing a multifamily unit to use as my primary residence and REI.

You can definitely find a nice SFR (Single Family Residence). 

I have my hands full trying to get the neighborhood network established, but with so many long-time residents sharing the same concerns, I know it will be ideal.