Finding handymen is NEVER easy:( Often, you have to use trial & error method and weed through several before finding one that is acceptably (never pefect) reliable, quality, will fix warranty issues and has decent prices.Try visiting a Home Depot 6-8am on a Saturday.

We have done tons of non-occupied flips too (fast method).

OP said: It’s frustrating, especially because our due diligence came back clean, leases were solid, and the property had just been fully renovated.

If you warned them and they didn't clean things up that could be a reason. 10.

As long as it cleans my bum I don't really spend a lot of time thinking about it, and I suspect most of your guests won't either.  

@Will ReedGet a second opinion from another company (one that just does cleaning and scoping not repairs as the companies that also do repairs tend to recommend repairs).

If one method of communication (email in this case) doesn't work, you need to try another way (phone call). 

It’s refreshing to see someone leveraging both traditional methods and community engagement... it’s a solid mix.

A clean U&O means the Seller doesn't have to do anything.The home inspector is a different issue.

Find Brandon's videos on YouTube for the "four square" method of analyzing homes and practice.