It wasn't rented out, I use it as an office, with the rest of the basement unit storing junk we couldn't find a place to put away.Long story short, there's no CO for the unit, prior owners had no permit for the work.

The one illegal conversion I personally dealt with only had a fine for work without a permit.

Check and see if the converted garage was permitted or do you need to get permits to convert and will they even allow that. 

I would think the architect could give budget estimates including development and permitting costs as well as construction costs? 

Long Term                                        Short TermMortgageTaxesHOA FeesWaterGas/ElectricInsuranceProperty managmentLawn CareSnow RemovalPool CareInternet/CableFurnishingsMaintenanceBooking feesVacancy Permits/Licenses

Always pull permits for all work and never underestimate what can hide behind panelling and drop ceilings!

And as time permits, I hope you post some more photos and updates on your BRRRR property. 

In CA the taxable rate is assessed at time of sale, and that tax basis is used to determine the taxes until the property is either sold or has permitted improvements (there is an inflation-adjusted increase allowed, but the starting # is the FMV at time of sale).

But how do you know if an addition is permitted or not?

Closing dates are unknown per their Agents, largely because the area is such as massive building zone and they are held up in permitting.