Unfortunately, this problem waste a lot of my time that could be spent on other investments.I have used the same tax professional for many years and he is very educated, but also much older than me and it's hard for me to understand all the reasons he has expressed why is better to put the rental on my personal tax returns.

We have run in to numerous accounts of this.

Theres not really a good reason to go out and find buyers if you dont have a deal.

Stating that they are using the mortgage of the investment property as a reason because it would put me above their threshold.

If so what were the circumstances and what was the reasoning?

I enjoy tenants turnover ever few years for the reason fair market rents tend to increase significantly year over year. 

You can list all the reasons why you charge $250 for a one-time shoveling, but nobody will care when there are other vendors doing the exact same job for $100 or less.I'm in a city of 10,000.

I love being on the other side charging everything possible on a credit card but there’s no reason to accept them.

Basically they'll come up with reasons as to why the "guarantee" doesn't apply to your situation. 

Clearly their pricing strategy isn't working for some reason.