Looking folks in the eye is still the best way to gut check your decision.

What do you do with the tenants when you gut out their bathroom? 

Does it need more substantial renovations like gutting a bathroom?

Trust your gut (as long as numbers work) Did you work with any real estate professionals (agents, lenders, etc.) that you'd recommend to others?

In my market we totally gut kitchens and baths.

You have a gut instinct from what I read that’s saying fire them. 

We did the gut of the property ourselves and I worked it out with the contractor to do some of the work to keep him rolling on bigger items.

However, I'm wondering if I can disqualify someone based on gut feeling?

Owner Occupied, live in gut rehab.Unit 2 (4D,2Ba) is second floor with finished attic.

I have worked a number of corporate jobs in the past and I've observed everything from a space being sold/leased as is to a space being gutted and stripped down to the bones to sell/lease.