Understand the fees involved and calculate the total cost for an entire year of management so you can compare the different managers.

Also getting 1.2% of monthly rent compared to the PP, is it really unrealistic to be able to cash flow?

Most of the comparable properties I have seen are lacking a 2nd full bath, or a garage.

I would compare the price of homes to what they would rent for after you PCS and make your decision based on what the numbers tell you.

I normally think long term is lower risk (occupancy, crazy renters, etc) but less margin when compared to short term. 

Other feedback was lack of storage and a garage which is par for most of our comparables since most of the nearby homes lack garages.Month Five (closer to three weeks):This month has been marketing the home at the $750 rate. 

I'd compare the cost of keeping the house versus what rents are in your area.

The cost is probably small compared to theft, fire, tornado, etc.

On average, after all the expenses, I make about $500 - $1000 more per month compare to long term rental.

Interview several banks with the same questions, put their answers on a spreadsheet to compare which has the best terms for your business.