there are plenty of variables that can be at play here.

Im originally a Mass boy myself. 

The end percentages each partner gets should be based on all of the job/roles each partner plays in the partnership. 

I am in BC and cashflow is difficult to achieve but if you are playing the long game you will come out ahead.

I got played by a couple tenants.

It has been extended towards the end of June 2021 so its going to be interesting how that's gonna play out.

I stopped using Craigslist a few years ago because there were so many issues with ads being stolen.I think how much rent you charge MAY play a role in the quality of the tenant you get. 

Sounds like they want to play the game, "Watch the Market Cycle" and buy another place if things cool down.Unless you have tons of assets to protect I wouldn't worry about renting to a lawyer.

Just to play devils advocate - It may be worth looking at taking the tax advantage of living in the house and not taking any capital gains tax when selling and capitalize on the current crazy market and go buy some better cash flowing assets in areas less expensive with better rent to purchase ratios.

If you take cash out beyond purchase price there are other rules that come into play.