Looking for my next primary residence with an investor's eye in case we move away and convert to a rental.

Your post caught my eye since you mention markets that I am heavily engaged in.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has published the results of research conducted into how lenders are likely to be doing their business in the future, and what new information and personal data these companies plan to start asking from borrowers in order to determine their credit score.The biggest takeaway is the seemingly inevitable shift from merely accessing credit information to also incorporating people’s online behavior into the process of deciding whether to lend them money necessary, for example, to buy a house.Compared to the way the system now works in most countries – these changes, which are expected to be coming soon, look fairly invasive privacy-wise, and with no “vision” of proper safeguards.

Rentometer is saying $1350, Zillow is saying $1400, and you are saying $1495 after originally listing at $1550.The house isn't bad by any means, but people eat with their eyes.

So I would make sure you keep your eyes open for pitfalls when absorbing other peoples teachings/wisdom, even mine, or especially mine :)  Go do your own homework, find other opinions and weight their ideas by their merit.

A name search says that possibly the old owner passed and this appears to maybe have been a rental property leading up to that in my eye.

@Lynnette E. Yes

Everything with the stair itself looks fine and good catch on the thicker treads.

What I see as the down side is the Loan will still show up on your DTI, granted the income from rent will offset it I would just check to see if the 2100 would be enough to offset in the eyes of a lender so you don't lock your self into a no house but mortgage situation without the ability to get financing.

It was a fire damaged, hoarder house when we first laid eyes on it.