INSURANCE: You will find Insurance costs for a Brick or Rock Property might costs SLIGHTLY less due to reduced exterior maintenance and exposure for the Insurance Carrier.

That said, in order to limit potential exposure I would propose that a detailed video walk through could be made for the property. 

The loans are still in our names, so not sure how much exposure that gives us.

It depends on the property - What is the risk exposure of the property?

In addition, many local MLS' syndicate listings with dozens of other sites.Since your list price is comparable with recent rentals, I think exposure is your issue right now.Also, you can try posting the rental on local Facebook groups.Best of luck to you moving forward!

@Jacob Rogers,In my case, I was out of work most of 1985 and got my first exposure to "the gurus" that summer: Robert Allen, Al Lowry and others I don't recall just now (it's late).

@Michael Bachmann Sometimes the deal isn't worth the legal exposure.

Most of the exposure will be automatic and included in all (or vastly most) MLS listings even as Entry Only: MLS exposure, Realtor.com, Zillow, Tulia, Redfin, Movoto, HousePads, HomeSnap, .... presence in other's Realtors and Brokerages websites (aka IDX syndication).

Meaning that if you allow them to get away with it now, they will certainly look to bend your rules and create more risk exposure for you in the future. 2) By not fully disclosing current information to you, there may be something he is trying to hide under the guise of not wanting his SSN floating out there somewhere.

The true purpose, even more than the money, is to get some exposure and experience.