Or, If I couldn't take it down (such as non compliant neighbor), and I felt it was deadly, I would probably move. 

I feel the time is good since theirs fear and people are hesitant because of rates not dropping, thus giving me a opportunity to make this move. 

From what I see it's not stellar in terms of population or job growth, but does look like it saw big price increases lately, I assume it's mainly population from Charlotte moving out to get more bang for their buck.If you're an investor with properties there I'd love to hear your thoughts on the market in general, how you see its potentail, the population I can expect as tenants, and things to pay attention to.

Let them break the lease and move. 

Spoke with two new PM's and will be moving over my properties to one of the two in the short term.  

I moved to columbus and so did thousands of other people for the opportunity and the economic development. look at the net migration patterns. that's what drives development, economies, etc. if you have some data to back up your investment thesis I'm all ears. but my focus is on Central Ohio new construction economy.

Let them know if they're not a good fit and you need to move on.5.

The tenant notified us that they will be moving out at the end of July when their lease is up.

@Nathan Frost- thanks .if you ae  able to get one loan that covers 5  rentals  at a 7.5% rate - this  is a good  deal  ( assuming loan fees arent too high ) ..shifting debt  is a good  move 

Bought the home, inherited a great tenant, and found a new tenant within 48 hours of the first tenant moving out.