I find no fault in my decisions and am resolute in my beliefs.

Disputing this seems like it wouldn't be worth the time although the blinds deduction was $158. 

Also, since you would be violating the TOS if accepting a personal payment, if the tenant was disgruntled and disputed say 6 or 12 months of rent payments, since you violated the TOS by accepting biz transactions through paypal they are just going to give that money back to the tenant and you are out all those months of rent.Venmo: I've seen landlords using Venmo for rent, but using a personal Venmo account in order to get the service for free.  

A clean break from the situation is a nice resolution.

Everything is in dispute now.  

I'm disputing unauthorized transactions with both banks,  TD and National Bank of Canada. 

Lol.Additionally, as a landlord, since you incurred a fee, technically you can send them to colelctions for the 35 dollar bounced check fee, which will do damage to their credit, and stay on their report for 7 years.Add an additional collectiosn on their for the collections agency in addition to your own, who is legally allowed to do so (most states allow for original debtor + 1 collection agency to report on a single debt), this makes it substantially more damaging to their credit, as each collections deals at least 20-80 points a piece (diminishing returns).Add a judgement for rent on top of that, as well as a collection set for the rents itself, and a separate set for the eviction costs (because those are separate from the actual rents), and you have pretty much a death kneel to their credit for upwards of 7 years, 10 if they end of fighting or disputing anything after the fact. 

I would not have the book keeper comparing the actual cash amount to a written figure on the envelope, I would have them compare the actual cash to the receipt log, because the receipt in your tenant's pocket is all that matters in a potential dispute.

I'm sure their is a mutually equitable resolution here.

And for less money, you could have purchased a used stove from a used appliance store.When it comes to items like stoves and refrigerators, I would rather find a solution that didn't take two weeks from tenant notification to the resolution of the problem.