@Troy SmithThe advice you received is correct.

I have a few rentals with section 8, and they are professionally managed.

I have a couple of friends who have several rental units in Gettysburg and said the rents are good and he has many professionals who stay for a good amount of time and pay on time.  

Having reasonable expectations, hiring a local professional (Realtor or PM), doing your research, and doing everything right (i.e. pro photos, professional design, good renovation, proper amenities and location, etc) are the keys to success in 2025.

ProfessionalA professional plumber can usually replace a kitchen faucet in 30–60 minutes.

Real estate agents in Ohio aren't allowed to lie about receiving other offers that don't exist, but I've seen it happen before.

With several large universities, including the University of Pennsylvania, Temple University, and Drexel University, the city has a steady stream of students and young professionals looking for rentals.

My question is this - does Johnson City receive enough visitation to justify a successful STR?

Make sure your photos are professional, your description is engaging, and you’ve set competitive prices based on your local market.

I’ve watched a lot of videos on how to screen and how to set up work with contractors, so I’m hopeful to build those relationships more in this area in the future.Did you work with any real estate professionals (agents, lenders, etc.) that you'd recommend to others?