I received the judges ruling in my favor today.

This situation seems a lot more of in the favor of the property owner rather than a situation where a property owner is trying to apply for multifamily zoning on a single family zoned property.Thanks again if you made it all the way through.

I would sell because the market is high in Northern VA and based on your cash on cash return which sounds not very favorable. 

Plus the laws are in favor of landlords.

Not the could do no wrong it was 5 years when I turned down all the rentals in fountain square for 30k each in favor or “less ghetto” areas lol.

Since (see Step 2) the tax law favors homeowners, they get a special extra break.

But there may be some factors in your favor.

Be aware that even though Airbnb may find in your favor, the guest can dispute it and request a refund. 

And, if I'm a judge and you're ONLY going the route of trying to force someone to stop something, without taking action on your end to avert costs, I'd look less favorably on your actions.

NJ Tenancy laws heavily favor the tenant.