I wanted to see: My rental address The date I purchased this propertyWhat type of dwelling it isThe year it was builtHow much I paid for itHow many square feetWhat I sold it for when and if I sell itWhen I received my Certificate of AcceptanceWhen I received my Certificate of OccupancyWhat would you like to see on your form?

It depends on the insurance company and rates you are going for.For example some insurance companies only insure brick buildings in certain areas built within the last 20 years.The reasoning is you get ultra low rates by having a low risk pool of properties.Insurance companies have told me with buildings 30 years or older some do not like to insure unless all mechanicals,plumbing,electrical has been replaced.The reason is statistics shows a high volume of claims happen after that age from things wearing out.With 4 units or less many just get the cheaper fire and dwelling coverage instead of a commercial policy.If the premium low rate insurers won't touch you there are companies who will give the policy to more properties deemed high risk but the policy of course will be higher and usually the deductible is too.

This is for  single family homes and two-to-four family dwellings. 

I would basically team with him to cover all costs for land and dwelling with possible help from a 3rd investor (Paying interest over time of loan) to Cash out Refi once everything is completed.  

Surely they were arrested after trespassing back into a dwelling they were legally evicted from right??

Most investors opt for the high deductible. have you tried going through your existing insurance company for car, life, etc. and see if they would give you fire and dwelling coverage?

@Tim Sutton - This is what the zoning code says about additional dwelling units13-196-740 One additional dwelling unit over original allowed – Conditions.

Our house is currently Q4: dwellings with this quality rating are residences of higher quality, built from individual or readily available designer plans in above-standard residential tract developments or on an individual property owner's site. 

How about landlord insurance (rental dwelling policy - if I recall that name correctly)?

I am an investor here in the Huntsville area and I agree with @Jason Bott  You could get one estimate from an insurance broker and compare to like and kind dwellings in that area.