Denis

And continue applying with property management companies, most they can do is deny you.I'd suggest writing up a simple one page cover letter about your story and what you've learned to hand in with the applications. 

They told me I could try, but I'd probably be denied. 

Apparently Redfin is a common vehicle for abuse (according to the rental company).   

So I want to be sure I am not in violation of the Fair Housing Law so wanted to pose a question:I am in the middle of conducting my pre-screening application for potential tenants, I denied someone who did not meet the requirements (this individual - lets name him GARY- his credit score was not 600+ and this individual was not a student).

I agree that paying the fees is not necessary but you can't deny the validity of the math.

I own sober living homes for men looking to recovery from substance abuse addictions.  

As far as your suggestions, if they have an "emotional support" letter from a medical professional, you cannot force them to produce pet insurance, no weight or age limits, and even breed restrictions are difficult, although you can possibly deny them if no insurance will cover you with that breed. 

My gut is to deny the tenant and cite the current monthly 3x income requirement, but was looking for a second opinion to ensure I'm not crazy.Sincerely appreciate any advice,Adam

Most Sec 8 tenants don’t abuse the system and are truly trying to earn more and get off the program and afford their own place.