My property manager said they will waive 1 month fees and marketing fees because of this but I am really pissed at the whole situation and am not sure how to handle thisYou need to do 2 things: 1) If you are 100% sure that they used a stolen credit card, you need to go to the police.

If you polish your tenant managing skills you won't have to look for the best "landlord-friendly states", you can buy cash flow properties around your town.

Contact the local police and see how many crimes of property damage they see.There's definitely money to be made in Sunnyside.

There is no rent police that prevents you from doing this...there may be tax implications, but that's not to say you can't do it.

Most are brick homes and most of my tenants are teachers, police and city workers.  

The Mayor and the police are at odds.  

Instead he called the police. 

If you have not tried independent agents who write commercial polices especially ones who deal with contractors and construction there may be some possibilities there.

Please go back to the morally policed section of BP where no humor is allowed and see how much learning is complete there.

If the seller stole them, did you make police report, or otherwise hold them accountable?