Pays on time or early, is very neat and treats my property as if it's their own, is just financially responsible enough to never be late on rent but irresponsible enough to never save up enough money to buy their own house.

But if I split them up I usually get good responses to all.

If you want to do it right (which you should do in this case), you'd have to put in a new common-area meter that both owners would be responsible for splitting. 

@Tairsa Mathews Sorry I just saw your response.

Thank you so much for your responses.

Alright, so I have been getting a couple different answers and I think I know the answer but I would like to get different responses from the BP community! 

Continue with your work and when you see her simply express your condolences and instruct her to contact you if she needs anything.

Thank you for your response.

I feel like this is fair bc it is when their lease ends, and I'm not responsible for giving them any extra time while they were trying to sort things out with their roommates to sign a new lease with me.Honestly, at this point, I'd rather have them out of my property as they've been difficult to deal with during this process and other items have popped up in the past (e.g. they've clogged our kitchen sink by pouring excessive oil down the drain, broke the garage door within a year of their first lease, etc.)My questions are:-What happens if only 2 of the tenants vacate when the lease ends and stay for an extra week?

Also utilities if you are responsible for paying them.