Ask me how to make your site credible.. then do as your MSOOTKAUG commands and make your site credible...then you pick your weapon of choice.

Your income is your biggest weapon, you are doing great on your assets, if you are into FIRE I am guessing your saving 50%+ per year?

I will wear a tool belt sometimes , hammers make great weapons , mag lights also are good defensive weapons.

Also included in this category were "certain types of calls or crimes that repeatedly require[d] police response," such as those involving weapons, drug sales, assaults and other criminal activities.

You can't carry a weapon without a proper permit.Be very careful!!  

On time payments, late fees, damages, pets, who lived there, dates, amount of rent, and the secret weapon only if they ask (would you rent to them again?)

As a veteran local market pro I can say yes, the "getto" can get rough, especially at this time, but getting shot up 2 times in such a short time, that's not an accident that's specific, and than the mention of vendors not going there because of tenants weapons, it sounds a LOT like you placed a tenant who is doing something that makes the place a target for such, especially by fact of your rent's being so high for the area.

Everything that is quaint and lovely will become a potential weapon against you.Can you separate the emotions of the past from the duties of the present?

But there are a lot of double standards and self righteous justifications out there.

If in fact it comes to that (and I doubt it because this tenant is a spendthrift and lazy) I have another weapon at my disposal.