I would just hire a quality general contractor, for example we have weekly updates via company cam photo and video documentation.

I am having a hard time finding insurance companies that insure properties owned under an LLC. 

Part of the issue I am experience is a DSCR company I spoke to will only give what I acquired the property for plus the rehab cast.

I am a licensed mechanical contractor and ran a commercial service company for around ten years, but never messed with new construction in that business.

To get top dollar for a renovated property you're going to have to clear the title as it would be very difficult, if not impossible, to find a title company that will write a policy for title insurance on a property coming from a tax sale.

New companies like Intel, Amazon, and Google are also investing here.

When you account for the FRBO's and companies such as mine that do not use MLS for listings, then there are a lot more rentals on the market.

I would see how your PM company is following up with leads and what their qualification restrictions are for the property.

Different company?

I try to buy a primary residence every few years to take advantage of the favorable financing with the goal to eventually turning them into rentals.My company does 20 Flips/BRRRRs per year in Jacksonville FL and we use a hybrid approach.