However, when I pulled the carpet up we found two different species of hard wood split down the middle of the space and one area where linoleum was glued to the hardwood. 

I have one tenant who likes to pay the day after he gets paid, so he pays half the rent in the middle of the previous month and half at the beginning of the month.

I am in the middle of a multifamily deal in a solid Class B part of Birmingham, and the rent/price ratio we are looking at is in the 18-20% range. 

In Columbus OH, you could rent a 2 bed/1 bath for 750-900 a month on the high end and Columbus is a lot more desirable than Middle town OH (I honestly didn't know of middle town till now and I have lived in Columbus for my whole life).

My rental is in a middle-class neighborhood and I would assume most prospective tenants will have a computer and a non dial-up service.

I'm in the County, there standing on your side of the fence in the middle, you are responsible for the "Right" side and the neighbor the "Left". 

They are upper-middle class homes.  

Someone could have built it in the middle of nowhere where mostly cheaper homes are.

I'm right in the middle of re-doing a kitchen myself & that's the look I'm aiming for.

Is $370k upscale for your area, or middle of the road?