I am leery because it is such a small deal…just 1 small 1 bedroom unit…and not a great a deal unless maybe you are local and have a use for it…walk to community college.  

DIL is a voluntary foreclosure.It is a loss mitigation option you have to apply for and be approved.

I own Granite and Pine Properties - a Direct to Seller Marketing company that focuses on giving sellers 3 selling options. https://graniteandpinere.com/My advertising is word of mouth, social media, SEO, mailers and cold callers.

We worked him through the process, brought him a contractor, and gave him all the resources along with giving him tips on layout and all.

Otherwise, they have to eat the extra expense just like homeowners do.I would talk to an attorney and your insurance company.

Quote from @Meliisa Lee: I recommend splitting the properties or selling them off and splitting the proceeds.

Welcome to the BP family and congrats on diving in. 

Property management is not for the faint of heart, so glad to see you're enjoying it and thriving.

Which ones did you try and how did it go? 

If your problems were really caused by an unexpected ac failure (can’t believe your realtor didn’t get seller to throw in a home warranty.) and not lifestyle.