Nick, if you are able to net $40k tax free, I think the question becomes would you be able to do something with that money that would improve your financial state faster than simply continuing to own your home? 

Something has to change or this will continue.

You can also ask if they like their CPA and plan to continue using them.https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/796/topics/39...https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/51/topics/352...https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/51/topics/500...2) Add the keyword alerts "New York City" and/or "New York".

A farmer will connect her, without self interest, and will continue to do so indefinitely.Ultimately the work can bear fruit many years down the line with a business opportunity, well after the salesperson has gained the prospect’s trust and respect.

You should feel relieved that he is going at this stage and that you have two months rent to cover your time to find a good replacement tenant.I would continue to demand the additional months rent according to the legal contract and threaten to take him to court to collect.

I understand 1000/yr isn’t a lot of cash flow but it seems like a decent/safe start if I continue adding more units.

I reckon you need to be out of Balloons, and into longer term fixed interest amortizations.If your past deals have proved to be successful, there's no reason why Lenders won't want your continued (or new) business.

If I went by the rental rule of 50% and it rents for $2000 per month now (and if I think that could continue), their list price of $215k is not even 1%...thats why i was wondering if I should look at it differently or lowball them lol.  

I also know a fantastic PM here, too, which might help you feel secure about continuing to invest in the area.So you're living in NY and your first two investments were in OH and PA? 

The bank makes the final decision on whether to accept the offer or not and continue to the process.