It is between Global Property Solutions LLC (GPS, LLC) and Empire Property & Investment Co.

@Nich J. there are probably 20-30 different insurance carriers who can provide you a solution, most of these companies are accessed through an independnat insurance broker.From your agents response, sounds like you are working with a personal lines agent. 

There arent really any made for you solutions out there like the gurus promise.

But my question is that we are concerned this will seriously detract from potential renters and I was looking to see if anyone had dealt with something similar or had any creative solutions to the problem.

My first two deals I found, negotiated, found bank financing, arranged/monitored rehab, and still manage myself (with by brother and sister as full business/equitypartners). 

If you don't think you will qualify now or it will be a stretch at best spending all of your money and or taking out more debt is not the solution.

Do you have a faulty water meter ask the utility folks.In west coast it is strictly monitored and enforced. $120-50 in the summer is typical for a family of 4-5.  

Not sure why this is biggerpockets but I'm sure there's some context I don't know.As a computer person I recognize what you're asking for : a solution to the travelling salesman problem.

There are many flippers here, I personally work with Corey Finnie with SD Flips, and Henish P with The Home solution Co.

I've spent a good bit of my free time educating myself - read some of the highly recommended books (RDPD, MREI, etc), monitored my local market closely using the MLS, drove around neighborhoods, attended open homes, read BP once a day, and finally caught up on all of the podcast episodes recently.