I bet they were valid.

Is this issue specific to Baselane or is this something broader that affects other platforms as well?

The fact its in a landbank tells me that it was taken back for some reason, which tells me its likely not a high commercial demand for development, but I could be wrong.If it is "on the main drag" in this town then I'd think doing a new build home to do a targeted and intentional air bnb would be the best bet. 

Your best bet is to find one that has flexible membership options, without high spend requirements.

I've bet on the stock market and I've played slow and steady income on the stock market.

Expanding your marketing to platforms like Craigslist, Apartments.com, Facebook Marketplace, and even Instagram could help get more eyes on your listing.

Hey @Mike Pepperday, AirBNB and VRBO are your best bet to see what kind of demand there is for STRs in general.

It became so bad I documented on other platforms that I do not list on CraigsList.   

I think you're best bet for private money is going to be to network at the meetups (Red Stick REI, RING) and on FB/here.

Padsplit is simply a technology platform.