Short of coming here and meeting face to face with them and come to a couple local REIA events to discuss, for those who are remote I would suggest getting into some of the NE Ohio REIA facebook groups to get some advice from locals.   

Yes, one approach is to continue with finding other cash flowing property.Let me suggest some other ideas for you to ponder, especially since you've also mentioned you are looking hard at DST's:What about Opportunity Zone funds? 

If that's the case I would strongly suggest building your team before pulling the trigger on an Airbnb.

But for Me, I use it... ive communicated with the app builders and they respond real quick if you have suggestions or comments.. it Cost$$ is the downfall I have..

I would suggest, if you are doing some proforma, keep it 8-10%.

Anyone could suggest any tips, resources, or builders/contractors they had worked with?

Given this is first investment, I would like to keep it local.Any suggestions on neighborhood with good rental cash flow in Middlesex county ?

Are you suggesting this wasn’t a result of pent-up demand but rather due to some other factor?

Need more information surrounding why your current lender is suggesting they cannot utilize the rental income on your investment property.

If not, I suggest you post what you're looking for in a separate post.