If you lived there for 2 years, they received 2 years of useful life and have no justification for billing you 100% of the replacement cost.

Their justification was that at one time the properties were a single Holiday Inn.  

I'm not super familiar with Georgia landlord/tenant laws, but here we typically file eviction as soon as the tenant is one month behind on rent unless they have justification to be late.

I was not really looking for an explanation or justification of their actions.

That kind of number should not be a justification for an argument point.

But they aren't right in every circumstance, and you may want to keep 1031s in your back pocket unless you have a well-thought out justification for going through the hassle of listing, selling, paying closing costs, searching for a new property under 1031 time constraints, and then buying two new properties. 

They interpret the statutes and rules and provide a letter to the client stating the justification for the transaction and the risk of an adverse ruling.

Perhaps there is one, but until that can be provided as justification for their decision it doesn't seem proper for USPS to be playing 'detective' telling people they can't hang a mailbox when there is a physical address on record with the county.Has anyone run into this too?

If they deny the incident entirely, then I would get a copy of the police report and use that as justification to send that lease violation notice and include a copy of the report so that they know they can't get away with lying to you.

Prepare a justification for your offer that includes market data and any necessary repairs or enhancements.Even if stability may be obtained with a fixed-rate 30-year mortgage, it's important to compare financing conditions.