There are 4 more 4 plex's for sale on the same street that are identical.

I was thinking of possibly taking out ~$50k which would make my monthly payments almost identical to what they are now. 

The floorplan is identical minus a 4th bedroom where I have a loft...

Those three, let's say identical buildings could have vastly different NOI's. 

You must first have knowledge, a plan, a business plan, a identity and somewhere along the way either at the beginning or sometime later create the entity that fits your individual need and end result.

What's key is that the data is close but not identical to the recorder's general index.

In an identical future case, this could establish the presence of the appliances before and their absence after a tenant moves out.I'm in agreement with other posters here... go after the ex-tenant in civil court (yeah, theft is a crime... yeah, it sounds like your cops are lazy... it could be worse) but as others have pointed out it's much easier to obtain a judgement in civil court. 

I thought Tenant Cloud was $9 a month with $2 to verify identity?

I like them in standard letter size (not in legal size) and the carbon copy makes it really easy to fill them out quickly and have identical copies with signatures for you and the tenants.The main advanatage is in their popularity.

NJ Landlord Identity LawEdit: Here's a quick list for other landlord-related laws if it helps.