Our lender has reached out and provided the discrepancies within his document as well as provided other comps that best support what we have done, and the appraiser will not budge. 

Take the flip profits now, or BRRRR with a great interest rate and some cash flow... doesn't keep me up at night bc both options are great, however I want to maximize my time and profits.For any multi-units I am heavy in the BRRRR category, but I have a couple San Diego condo deals I am in contract on now and curious the thoughts from BP on which route is better... and I typically don't like holding condos long term due to the HOA and the low ceiling on cash flow, but another perspective I have heard is how easy they are as a rental.I got in to this for long term wealth #1 and short term profits #2... just an FYI.Condo #1:*This deal is under contract and ready to close in a few weeks using HM at 85% of PP and 100% of Rehab with 9/2.PP: $155,000Rehab: $30,000 - $32,000ARV: $260,000 with upside as nothing has sold in building in 2 yearsHOA: $300 a moRental: $1750-$1800PITI w/ HOA from Refi ~ $1,500Minimal VacancyBRRRR Pros: In a predominantly rental area, can 100% BRRRR and hold for $250-$300 a mo cash flow.Flip Pros: I'm licensed so it'll only cost me about 4% cost of sale Condo #2: *This deal is in negotiations with bank for Short Sale using HM at 85% of PP and 100% of Rehab with 9/2.PP: $150,000 - $200,000 (Discrepancy because we are negotiating... starting at 150k, closer to 200k will lean me towards flip vs BRRRR)Rehab: $28,000 - $30,000ARV: $295,000 HOA: $388 a moRental: $1800PITI w/ HOA from Refi ~ $1,600 or less, depending on purchase price/refi priceMinimal Vacancy, Brand new hospital being build walking distance, less cash flow but better area than Condo #1BRRRR Pros: In a predominantly rental area, can 100% BRRRR and hold for $200-$300 a mo cash flow.Flip Pros: I'm licensed so it'll only cost me about 4% cost of sale---TL;DR - Are condos good for BRRRR or better to flip and keep my rentals as multis or high cash flow SFR's

I can understand why one would have a listing that the other one doesn’t but why would there be a discrepancy in the “Sold” properties?

It’s even worse when there’s an issue such as a meter/address discrepancy, unpaid balance, lien, etc.

This way you’re covered by Airbnb if there’s a discrepancy of funds between you and your traveler.

When house hunting my first home I used zestimate as a ballpark estimate in placing offers .Now that I am planning to sell my home I see that zestimate is awfully skewed as other highly similar homes in my neighborhood are zestimated at a much higher price and and I presume most potential buyers perceptions are colored by the zestimate tool in zillow.Is there anything I can do to address this discrepancy in zestimate?

I'm still learning all this so please let me know if you see any discrepancies.

Everyone was shocked to learn of the discrepancy.

It'll likely be closer to $6k taking into account everything which means my cash to close and cash on cash is lower, but my biggest sticking point is the potential discrepancy in rental income.

I'm sure there are lots of people out there that have had appliances walk after an inherited tenant move-out or a lawsuit over a discrepancy in security deposit.