The REI market in USVI is very unique as property values are being held down by economic pressures providing the opportunity for low buy in.Here's the link to the listing in case you are interested:  https://listings.coldwellbankervi.com/idx/details/listing/b3...

Economic conditions, community developments, and market demands constantly reshape the landscape.

. #2 Research the various markets you're looking into (population / job / economic growth currently going on in those markets) and then make your selection. #3 Start working with an investor focused lender / realtor / property manager and get good at analyzing numbers. #4 Once you're comfortable with everything and you find a deal you like, pull the trigger.

Will it be enough to make up for the lack of income growth, buyer sentiment, unknown economic plan for after the election and the high valuations of properties?

In my experience, economic vacancy is typically more than 8%.Your NOI calculation is not correct.

That was the entire premise behind raising the FFR - to slow down economic activity by making financing more expensive. 

I realize the current economics are great for those goals but that is my goal.

Labor Day sales showed shoppers seeking bargains, reflecting heightened concern over inflation and economic uncertainty.

.- Diverse Property Portfolio: The area seems to have a mix of both residential and commercial properties, which could allow for diversification in your investment strategy.Strategic Location: Shelby's proximity to global markets via nearby airports, rail, and port facilities could make it attractive for businesses, potentially driving demand for both commercial and residential real estate.Potential Challenges- Economic Concerns: The unemployment rate of 13.0% is relatively high, which could impact the overall economic stability of the area and potentially affect real estate values and rental demand.- Price Discrepancy: There's a notable difference between the median listing price ($295,000) and the average home value ($201,945).

Not unreasonable to ask them to cut it down IMO.I would sue private nuisance and injunction from maintaining a private nuisance, and for interfering with prospective economic advantage (scaring away potential tenants with prospect of dwelling and car damage).Start with a nasty-gram from lawyer since you already asked and was turned down.