I do think you need a separate entrance option or at least two entrances in a four-plex to make it easier on the LTR tenants, but if you are open about it form the start, everyone gets it and you choose the unit composition based on which ones will be STR or MTR.

During the Lula setup process, select "I will choose which maintenance requests will be sent to Lula" instead of opting for all requests to be sent automatically.

I’d recommend looking into this in conjunction with whatever other program you choose.

We'd have to cash-flow $1,300/mo over that period to make that much, which isn't happening.This is all to say that if you are in a market that has good long-term appreciation potential, then whatever rental model you choose is simply a way to make a little money while you hold the property for larger long-term gains.I'll let others chime in on your specific area.

What factors should I prioritize when choosing the best approach for my future success in real estate? 

Many of our investors choose areas that have low land cost and steady population growth.

To invest in Section 8 housing, look at areas such as Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, and Dayton, choose safe neighborhoods, study Section 8 standards, analyze property types, and explore financing choices.

Can we all agree a dollar made in Austin TX or Bryan TX or Dallas TX or San Francisco CA, or Nashville TN or any where spends the same wherever you choose to spend that dollar.  

I get bombarded with inquiries and have lots to choose from.

Living in the property for two years likely allowed you to claim the capital gains exclusion... up to $250K for singles or $500K if married.