Ironically, the opposide is true for the ones that don't look great for years 1-5 or so. 

Ironically you continue to teach me with your posts.

Usually the dad "worked in construction during the summers in college (30 years ago)", "wouldn't take this house if the sellers paid me" or "used to have rentals back when it made sense, and this place is a piece of garbage, look at this old galvanized water pipe, this is what you need to look out for kid (points to a black iron gas line)". 

Ironic that an algorithm designed to protect hosts by punishing guests is causing outrage when host's #1 complaint is that airbnb too often favors guests at the expense of hosts.  

I can pocket quite a bit of money laundering and ironing my own shirts, having my wife clean the house, changing my car oil, mowing the lawn, and brewing my own Starbucks coffee. 

Cracked vent pipe like that picture showed would make it smell from the old cast iron leaking gases.

That's wrong tenant he is trying to cut loose from, ironically... 

Ironically I sold my investment property in Tempe, AZ last year and invested in Worcester, MA which is where I work as an agent. 

I don't necessarily provide all of these (seems like a lot of face tissue), but it's helpful.InventoryKitchenCooking utensilsTable settingsNapkins/paper towelsDish soap/dishwasher detergentHand soapTea towels/washcloths/spongesSalt/pepper/oil/sugar/etc.Coffee/tea/milk/etc.Cleaning suppliesBathroomsTowels/washclothsHand soapShampoo/body washToilet paperToothpaste etc.BedroomsSheetsBlanketsPillowsFace tissueClothes hangersLiving roomDecorative pillowsThrow blanketsFace tissueRemotes I'd add:TV'sCharcoal grillOutdoor furniture, fire pitwasher/dryerPool table or other entertainmentiron, ironing board coffee pot, toaster  crock pot, blenderglasses, mugspots/pansoven Mitsubishicutting boardscolandercan openerwine cork screwI'm sure there is more.

I think John Adams and Alexander Hamilton would be there with their shootin' irons protecting their property.