But this is precisely the reason I wanted to post this question--to get insights from people who with different experience and perspective.

In the future, if you're a landlord, remember that these are your customers and try to approach your business from that perspective. 

I look at every property on its own merits.I know others will disagree and that’s great, the more varied the perspectives the better.

There are certain income thresholds were this is not the case.In short, there are a lot of ways to structure a short term rental property along with  your business from a tax perspective to make it a lucrative investment.

I'm hoping perspective guests feel the same way.

I would take a look at a couple different things, at least speaking from a tax perspective. 

And economically, they aren't wrong, that would be the highest and best economic outcome from a valuation perspective.

I understand your perspective.

I'm interested in hearing different perspectives.

The perspective is skewed since you are already in the industry.