OTH, if they had a bankruptcy last year and prior they had years of bad credit, they may not cure the problem in 3 years, a lender may want to see 5 years of good behavior.

If you haven’t already, IMO your #1 objective at this time is to address the personal behavior and events that led to your credit score.

They are long term tenants and this issues had been going on for years, anyways I tried to establish and reminded everyone of the rules and expected behavior when dealing with one another when I first got the place to only find out it made little to zero effect.

My questions, does he have a winnable case and should I contact the California Bureau of Real Estate for what appears to be unethical behavior? 

I can't stand this and I think others feel the same about this general behavior of Realtors.

:)  Most should start by calling a banker then if banker says no dough then move on to more unconventional.....How much money an investor has access to is going to drive buying behavior more than what you want your criteria to be & this will drive you on how to find leads.

I've literally never heard of anyone whose loan servicer invoked that clause whose ONLY naughty behavior was the LLC thing. 

I never spoke to Victoria in any way that would merit this sort of behavior. 

It's funny that anything less than a five-star review is considered "Karen" behavior.

The problem I see is that your succumbing to the irrational behavior of wanting to get out at the worst possible time.