Tiles had to be removed which created a lot of dust. 

Lots of dust with tile removal.

If you want to give me a specific fact pattern, message me privately. 

This is second story and has tiles.

I'm not a contractor and don't do anything structural, but I would consider my brother in law and myself - experts at tile, kitchen, flooring renovations. 

you would do the public good to file a complaint with the DRE in your state and send the fact pattern to Insurance commissioner filing a complaint against the tile company .. and send to the local DA and AG.. 

And what is your experience with Rustoelum Tub & Tiles?

I can tell you a bathroom let's say that is getting an overhaul: new toilet, new vanity, new tub, new tile you are looking at 8 - 10k. 

All the improvements I am doing is going under this category (new bathroom, new plumbling, new kitchen cabinets, new tile, new flooring, appliances, etc...)I dont know how classify my labor expense.

I moved to columbus and so did thousands of other people for the opportunity and the economic development. look at the net migration patterns. that's what drives development, economies, etc. if you have some data to back up your investment thesis I'm all ears. but my focus is on Central Ohio new construction economy.