Use one of your free 10 reports on Rentfinder.ai, in addition to the standard comparable analysis from Zillow.

Also I am thinking now that these are small rural counties with population in the entire county probably no more than 50k or so.. at least with most of those folks living in the city of Oroville which is right on the border with British Columbia In my flying days I would go into Oroville to get through US customs compared to going into one of the airports Airports north of Seattle .

I would consider the cost of extracting your equity from the FL property by sale and then compare that to pulling equity by way of a cashout refinance.

As for NY which is from what I see a very complicated state compared to Trustee sale states the thing to do and the ONLY thing to do..

Comparing what was promised to what was delivered lacks context. 

If they do not qualify because of poor credit or income issues compared to being self employed etc there are differences - but typically people don’t qualify due to poor credit and people will seller finance to these borrowers thinking they woke up at a holiday inn and got a finance degree when in reality they repeat their past mistakesRemember the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result

With margin trading of 20-25% of initial investment, when stocks market collapses with dollar cost averaging as a strategy  , leverage of the initial investment in stocks, the AAR can be more.comparable to most syndication (compared to 20% down payment in real estate).I have been following BP forums for the last 4-5 months and have spent almost 4-500 hours.

This is such a personal question no one can really answer it for you, call around to your local CPA's and compare.

Compare that number to the odds of being struck by lightning, and then act accordingly. 

Comparable sales are the most reliable way to determine value.