I struggle w/ the ethics of walking away.You juiced the property for $61K (350 - 289) and now you're struggling with the ethics of the situation.

That being said, based on Daniel's comments, this may not be a low hanging fruit, but I suspect that for the experienced property manager there would be money to be made here. 

Now that's not to say you can't go for low hanging fruit (long tail keywords) but the world of SEO is about getting good traffic more so than being number one on Google.  

It will be low hanging fruit in the hands of an ambulance chaser to prove there was owner neglect if you decide one day to "tell the tenants they need to go to the shed and fire up the snow blower"What do you do when the snow blower is out of gas?

That will probably take more cash to get in now, but may provide more fruit later.

@Marian Smith I just finished renovations on my current house and my wife would like to enjoy the fruits of my labor for a few years before we sell. 

I still think we have some juice left in the market and rental rates but the margins are really tightening up. 

I view multifamily as essential to juicing the return of a portfolio but I love the flexibility and upside of quality SFRs.

BP is a great way to get those calculated-risk juices flowing!

As exciting as it is to get started, pick the low hanging fruit and do something!