Prices have gone up which is why this new one will only cashflow $800 but they are pretty identical.

@Etim Fisk5 of the 6 properties I bought were full when I bought them.1 was empty and in good shape ready to rent (had bad management)That 1 property is more profitable than identical properties next to it because I was able to screen my tenants and start them out at market rate or higher rents.If you're in a decent mark and the deal is right you shouldn't have a problem filling it

You can nitpick if you'd like but they're pretty darn close, if not identical .  

Here's what doesn't make sense in your numbers:  Your scheduled and effective gross income are identical. 

But the concept, putting a buyer and a seller together and collecting a fee, is almost identical to wholesaling.

It might be priced double what the identical building next door is priced at.

They can flag your credit history as "fraud victim" and nobody will be able to get credit with that identity without providing extra information.Jon

They are right next to each other, adjacent lots, both FNMA properties.Both buildings have identical floor plans.

I think if you had two identical homes, one with blown out ceilings one with 8 footers. 999 of 1000 would want to buy/rent the high ceiling house.

Then later I see them for less with the identical information but they always leave out the phone number.