Hey Marc,First, I would need to know the goals of this LLC, as operating agreements vary widely in purpose. 

As a region, the phrase “The Poconos” is linked to a wide variety of areas that have much of the same allure in common.

Let's turn this crystal ball a little bit, and look at OWC from another angle.

This is the angle I'm attacking. 

Quote from @Milton Chamberlain: Hi Joe,KC provides a wide variety of investment opportunities with its cultural city point and wide variety of standalone suburbs and (further out) rural farm communities.

This allows for a wide variety of ways to achieve the goal thru all aspects of real estate; investing in assets that have great capital gains potential but may not cash flow (options, land, redevelopment, gentrification, etc. ) utilizing “fee income” to build my estate (syndication, brokerage, partials, participations), and “creating” high yielding notes, and “creating” wealth through creative real estate buying, selling and exchanging. 

This is Los Angeles City-wide:

Like Jaron said, consider it from all angles to make sure you have multiple exits. 

You have to know your market competition from every angle (price, offerings, perks, marketing, quality of furniture, neighborhood etc) You can overcome negative reviews if you do a lot of volume, that is almost a given to not be able to make everyone happy or foresee every issue a guest may have.

Looking at the data you provided for Melbourne, FL:- Average rent is around $2,000-$2,100- Rents have actually decreased slightly year-over-year- There's a wide range of rental prices ($650 to $6,500)This suggests a diverse market with potential opportunities, but also some volatility.