Dump the thing and either hang on to the cash while you find a performing asset or 1031 into something that does perform.

For STRs, properties near the beach or downtown tend to perform well.Start Small and Smart: If this is your first property, focus on something manageable.

It has been a steady performer for both appreciation and cash flow over the years.

I found similar patterns between all 5 companies: namely, they had taken on too many units, were over-charging me for things I didn't need, and weren't handling issues correctly (they would send out vendors who didn't know what they were doing, mis-diagnose issues etc.)No disrespect to the PMs on this chain or BP in general, but any third-party manager won't perform exactly the way you would like them to simply because of the constraints they are faced with as far as having so many units and owners to keep tabs on. 

On the flip side, saving for another property could delay financial stability if unexpected costs arise.A Balanced ApproachIf you’re still torn, consider a hybrid strategy:-Focus on maximizing your current STR’s performance.

Especially when there are other software's out there that perform these tasks in addition to all the other features investors liked about Buildium.

Spend at least four hours a day on prospecting and lead generation.What are the best ways a new agent performs prospecting and lead generation?

If it’s cash flow, selling might make sense to reinvest in a better-performing asset.

He wasn’t performing for me, he was just giving me super helpful, targeted advice.

In the end a solid turnkey company will still be able to provide a performing asset to their investors.