I realize that there are variables from market to market and property to property that could make VRBO more effective for a given property, but my understanding is that in general Airbnb bookings get out to such a dominant start in regard to percentage of the bookings, that VRBO and other lesser OTAs have trouble catching up.

I personally would fix the 3 windows and maybe consider cutting the rent a little more to gather more interest. 

Real estate investment is my future.This amazing voyage begins with setting personal goals and vision.

Cosmo - I personally don't know Phoenix well, but if I had to do this in another city I would look at income levels, crime levels, and population growth (if you can) by zip code and/or area within a DMA as a starting point.

I personally walked and researched every property prior to investing to understand what I was buying, what could be done to add value and what I should expect in cash flow and appreciation.Learning what makes a good investment for you is absolutely necessary. 

I personally would recommend it but it isnt the best run 3 day. 

Data point: we have a long-term rental in a popular STR neighborhood listed through Zillow right now.Every person who writes asking to do some sort of arbitrage is blocked by the Zillow platform.I don't even have to say "no thank you anymore."  

He really is a proactive person.

Was that person me or another person as that sounds like something I have been telling people? 

I realized this again when we had a traveler cancel her lease about a week before moving in.